www.wholelattelove.com: our caffeinated commitment to you

It's the Barista, Stupid

Beginner or pro barista, all are invited to share.

Link to "It's the Barista, Stupid"by HB on Fri May 20, 2005 9:58 pm

This site features high-end espresso machines and the reviews of these beautes draw most of the readership. So it's a little ironic that I list the Macchina espresso (espresso machine) dead last in the four principle elements of making espresso. For your reference, I defined them earlier in the Feature Spotlight on Grinders and have excerpted them below (emphasis added):

    The Four M's

    The principle elements of making espresso are captured in four Italian words:

    1. Mano dell'operatore (hand of the operator)
    2. Macinadosatore (grinder-doser)
    3. Miscela (blend)
    4. Macchina espresso (espresso machine).

    Each of these elements plays an important role and the strength in one rarely compensates entirely for the weakness in another.

    I've ordered these factors by what I believe are their relative importance. You may be surprised to see the espresso machine ranked last. This isn't to suggest it isn't important-- it obviously is --but rather recognition of your ability to adapt your barista technique to obtain the best result. To put it another way, above a certain level in espresso machines, the majority of improvements are more about quality of materials and workmanship, capacity, and ease of producing the desired result than an "absolute potential." What further proof does one need than sampling a half-dozen commercial cafes? Practically all cafes purchase from among the best equipment available, but invariably a few outshine their peers thanks to their superior baristas.
If you've read a few of this site's reviews, you may have noticed the four M's defined more than once. At first I only wrote short definitions, not really assigning any relative importance. In the above article, I thought it worth explicitly stating (a) the machines aren't everything, and (b) the barista is the most important. OK, it would more accurate to say that the machine isn't the critical factor above a certain point. While a barista champion could make do with lesser equipment thanks to their heightened skills, the average home barista has a fraction of the experience. Arguably top-notch equipment will deliver better results for them because its superior capabilities in terms of temperature control, stability, pressure regulation and preinfusion, thereby reducing the burden on the barista to adapt to maladaptive equipment.

Does that mean you must drop three grand to have a great espresso machine? Most certainly not! At today's prices, a prosumer espresso machine starting at around a grand will reliably and quickly deliver good results without an undue amount of effort. That isn't to say that higher tier equipment isn't a joy to use -- indeed they are! -- rather it's analogous to the audiophile world where the cost rises faster than the "absolute potential" of the result. And especially in the realm of commercial equipment, capacity and consistency under load is the name of the game and much of the reason behind higher sticker prices.

On a related note... There's a lot going on behind the scenes of HB. The site moderators and potential writers are hashing over future articles. Looking at the list that's planned to come online, it's frightening. There's only so many evening hours and all of us have full-time jobs and other responsibilities. But for me and others who've joined "Team HB", the excitement of doing something new and innovative is pure fun, albeit frequently exhausting.

One particular article has been on the radar for months, even before the domain existed and long before forums were even a consideration. I don't want to spoil the fun (or build up unjustified excitement), but it's jokingly entitled "It's the Barista, Stupid". Partially an equipment showdown, partially an opinion piece, it strikes at the central core of what defines this website: The people, the barista, the human experience.

We hope you enjoy many hours reading about very cool espresso equipment, barista toys, and how to refine your espresso preparation skills. But remember the tools of the trade are secondary to you. What you learn and share here is what makes the difference, whether your equipment costs $500 or $5000. Take advantage of the human knowledge at your fingertips. Participate. Join the HB experiment!
Dan Kehn
User avatar
HB
 
Posts: 7062
Joined: Apr 29, 2005
Location: Cary, NC

Link to "It's the Barista, Stupid"by miKe mcKoffee on Wed Jun 08, 2005 7:23 pm

Just a quick note of thanks to you and the other's who have worked to bring this focused forum to fruition. Those who may know me from Sweet Maria's email chat List know I can, uh, get carried away on tangents at times. If I do here, feel free to knock me back in line! (Of course, being a moderated forum that's simple - delete).

I still say I'm not a full fledged Espresso Hound, merely a pup. I hope to continue learning from those who have paved the way before me.

BTW, pulled a hilarious shot of SM Monkey Blend today. This time I was sure I'd stalled Missy on the barely rest ready Monkey (2&1/2day rested 12min roast just to edge of 2nd, PID 231 boiler temp). 21sec into the shot and not a drop. A wee flow finally started at 22sec so I ran the shot long to 29sec. Total volume including mostly crema about 1/3oz, seriously less than a tablespoon, I checked volume afterwards with water. (from LM double basket load).

I've learned to never dump a short shot so took one quick slurp and man was it thick, smooth, yummy, and gone. Adjusted grind and pulled a more reasonable 1&1/4oz double...
User avatar
miKe mcKoffee
 
Posts: 1076
Joined: Jun 03, 2005
Location: Vancouver, WA, USA


Return to Tips and Techniques